Call FREE from a Landline or Mobile on 0800 634 75 75

Gloucestershire cyclist pothole compensation claim rejected

Pothole claims can be very hard to win – that’s why you need the best legal advice!

This story comes from the BBC and covers a cyclist who has made a claim for personal injury compensation having rode over a pothole and been injured as a result. Cyclists are one of the most vulnerable victims of pothole accidents, and the injuries the victim can end up with can be fairly serious.

The case here of the cyclist in the BBC news article is testament to this – he broke his collarbone and hit his head hard when he fell victim to a pothole. So why has this case been rejected by the council?

The Law

The way the law works when it comes to pothole compensation claims makes it extremely hard to win against a council or a local authority. The Highways Act 1980 puts a duty on the council to have a reasonable system of inspection and maintenance to look out for defects like potholes, and to sort out reported ones as quickly as possible.

Section 58 of this act gives the council a special defence against a claim if they can prove that they had a good enough system of inspection, and that they have kept to it. There is also a minimum size criteria as well, which means that a defect is only seen as dangerous enough to rectify if it is of a certain size. The law doesn’t necessarily have a specific measurement criteria, but the general rule lawyers and insurers use is the “one inch rule” that can mean a pothole that is less than an inch deep is not seen as a defect to act on.

What this means

What this means is that you could trip and fall on a huge pothole on a road that is inspected every, say, six months. If the road you fell on was last inspected five months ago, and the pothole that caused your accident was not there at that point, the council will defend the claim and argue that the pothole must have formed after their last inspection. Because the next inspection isn’t due for another month, they can argue that the pothole has appeared between inspection intervals. As such, they may not be liable.

When it comes to the size, they could inspect a road and they could find a pothole that is half an inch deep. But because it isn’t at least an inch deep, they could just leave it on the basis that it is not deemed dangerous enough to warrant intervention.

So how do I win a pothole compensation claim?

If we can prove that the pothole has been there for longer than their inspection periods, we can win a case. But this can be very difficult to do. We could argue that the system is not good enough for the area as well, but it’s normally the case that roads are inspected more frequently based on how busy they are.

If the pothole has been reported and the council has failed to do anything about it quickly enough, we could win a claim. But defining how quick they have to act is not necessarily easy as there are no hard and fast rules as such. It is sometimes accepted that they should rectify it within at least four weeks or so.

In this case, the cyclist in the BBC news article, allegedly swerved to dodge several potholes but was unable to avoid one which caused the accident. The council alleged that there were no defects present four weeks before the accident, presumably based on their inspection records, and in addition they argued that it was below their accepted danger threshold when it comes to measurements. The report states that it was 38mm deep, falling just short of their danger threshold of 40mm.

As such, the council here actually have two points to defend the claim on it would seem. But one thing that has been raised is that the pothole was apparently still there two months after the accident. Whether this can be raised as an argument in favour of the victim here could be down to exactly when the council were made aware of it, and what their system of inspection was for that road.

So is this fair?

Well the law is the law, and they appear to be defending the claim based on the classic arguments. Unfortunately they seem to be able to argue both on this occasion – alleging the pothole wasn’t there on their last inspection, and arguing it wasn’t deep enough to be classed as something they need to action.

A spokesperson said: “The well used roads in the county are inspected at least every month. Unsafe potholes are fixed within 24 hours, and others, if they meet the national safety requirements, will be repaired within 28 days which is in line with UK guidelines.”

That being said, we have seen many instances where this has been found to be inaccurate. There are many ways and means we can use to find out whether a defence being raised by a council is a good enough one or not.

Call us on 0800 634 7575 to get your pothole compensation claim started today, or if you prefer why not arrange a callback from one of our team, for instant FREE advice on whether you have a claim to make! Just fill out the quick form below and we’ll call you when you have time to speak.

You can also get in touch by using our LiveChat facility, which you’ll find in the bottom right of the screen, our expert Claims Team are always on hand to deal with your compensation questions.

IMPORTANT: advice on this page is intended to be up-to-date for the 'first published date'.

Request A Call Back

Fill Out Your Details

Your privacy is extremely important to us. Information on how we handle your data is in our Privacy Policy.
You have the right to object to the processing of your personal data.

NHS Email Leak
Search Our Blog
Free Instant Valuation
Compensation Calculator
Instantly Values Your Claim

Instantly value your claim for a head injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a neck injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a shoulder injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for an elbow injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for an arm injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a hand injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a torso injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a mid-section injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a back injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a leg injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for a knee injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Instantly value your claim for an ankle/foot injury!

  Minor    Moderate    Severe

Find out how much your injury claim is worth!

Click on the injured body part to get your INSTANT FREE personal injury compensation valuation texted to your phone within seconds...

  Yes    No   Yes    No   Yes    No

Your privacy is extremely important to us. Information on how we handle your data is in our Privacy Policy.
You have the right to object to the processing of your personal data.

Latest Blog Posts

Loss of limb compensation claims advice

Loss of limb compensation claims advice

Loss of limb compensation claims are naturally serious, and anyone suffering this kind of injury must seek the advice of a specialist serious injury solicitor ASAP. And this is where we come in. As...

Published on the 05/08/2020


Medical negligence compensation claim advice

Medical negligence compensation claim advice

If you need to make a medical negligence compensation claim, we may be able to offer you specialist representation on a No Win, No Fee basis. In this article, we can briefly outline when you could ...

Published on the 22/07/2020


Pelvic mesh inquiry shows patients have been failed

Pelvic mesh inquiry shows patients have been failed

Media coverage of the pelvic mesh inquiry results has led to a new wave of people contacting us for help and advice about No Win, No Fee compensation claims. The brief of the findings is that there...

Published on the 08/07/2020


Chronic pain compensation advice

Chronic pain compensation advice

When it comes to chronic pain compensation claims, the best practices to pursue them and how we calculate the amounts in damages can require a great deal of skill and expertise. As specialist lawye...

Published on the 23/06/2020


Dental negligence compensation claims

Dental negligence compensation claims

We have represented a huge number of people for dental negligence compensation claims on a No Win, No Fee basis, and we may be able to help you too. Here, we will briefly outline when you could be ...

Published on the 09/06/2020


Private treatment with compensation claims

Private treatment with compensation claims

Obtaining private treatment with compensation cases is something that we can offer as part of a No Win, No Fee claim with the expert team here at The Injury Lawyers. There are options for being abl...

Published on the 27/05/2020


Burn injury claims for compensation

Burn injury claims for compensation

Burn injury claims can be some of the most serious types of cases that we take forward for victims on a No Win, No Fee basis. Here’s a little advice about whether you could be eligible to launch ...

Published on the 13/05/2020


Claim compensation for a roof accident

Claim compensation for a roof accident

A roof accident can lead to serious injuries for people and workers alike, and you may be entitled to ...

Published on the 29/04/2020


Cancer compensation claims

Cancer compensation claims

Cancer compensation claims: not an area of our expertise that most people want to have to think about, let alone make use of. But it is important that victims can access some form of justice for what ...

Published on the 15/04/2020


Serious spinal injury compensation claims

Serious spinal injury compensation claims

When it comes to a serious spinal injury compensation claim, there’s a great deal that needs to be considered. Choosing the right law firm to represent you is also incredibly important. In this k...

Published on the 02/04/2020


Categories
Archives