Call FREE from a Landline or Mobile on 0800 634 75 75

Law On Accidents Due To Sudden Stop

Generally speaking if Person A caused his or her motor vehicle to crash into the back of Person B’s motor vehicle, then Person A would be at fault. This is of course a typical rear end shunt scenario whereby liability is usually attached to the driver who drove his or her vehicle into collision with the vehicle in front. As a driver myself, this must be the correct decision as you have no control over the vehicle that is driving behind you. However in some strange and unusual circumstances Person B in the above scenario could be held at fault.

You would generally have to look at the reason why Person B stopped so suddenly and without warning. When a sudden stop was made due to a traffic sign or signal, the driver is highly unlikely to be held at fault if another vehicle crashes into the back of him.

There may be a need to stop suddenly if, for example, a child runs out into the road. In this scenario it is of course reasonable to stop suddenly and it is highly unlikely that you would be held at fault if another vehicle crashes into the back of you. I could never say that it is impossible to be held at fault in these situations as every case is taken on its own facts.

You could be at fault if you stopped suddenly and without warning for no good reason. Even if your vehicle was not involved in the accident itself, you could still be held at fault. Say for example Vehicle A stopped suddenly and without good reason, Vehicle B managed to stop in time but Vehicle C crashed into the back of Vehicle B. If there was no good reason for Vehicle A to stop suddenly then they may be held liable for the accident. In these cases of extenuating circumstances the person who stopped suddenly may be at fault. There is no strict rule on this area of law as every case is considered based on its own unique facts. It appears that the questions that must be asked are:

  1. What caused the diver to stop so suddenly and without warning?
  2. Was it reasonable for the driver to stop so suddenly and without warning?

In Gussman v Gratton-Storey the Defendant applied her breaks violently in order to avoid hitting a pheasant running across the road. The driver behind was unable to stop and collided with the Defendant’s vehicle. The Defendant was held liable so in this case the sudden stop was in effect held to be unreasonable. The lead driver was held liable in this case. You can see the difficult precedent that this case sets. It leaves a difficult decision as to just when it is reasonable to stop suddenly. For example, would one animal running into the road cause a reasonable sudden stop and another animal running into the road cause a sudden stop that was unreasonable? It is a bit like deciding which animals you can drive over and which you must treat as though it were a human.

Each case is considered on its facts; if you collided into the back of another vehicle then it is likely that a Court would hold you at fault. However if the car in front stopped suddenly without any or any good reason, then the driver of the vehicle that stopped suddenly may be at fault. Say the driver stopped suddenly due to ducks in the road, a Court may say that this was an insufficient reason to brake and stop suddenly.

Such cases may inevitably result in huge liability arguments. There may be a disagreement as to who is at fault. Therefore it is essential that you seek independent legal advice.

We are specialist personal injury lawyers, so do not hesitate to call us today on 0800 634 75 75.

Request A Call Back

Your Details
Accident Details
Select Your Call Back Time
NHS Email Leak
Search Our Blog
Free Instant Valuation
Compensation Calculator
Instantly Values Your Claim

Instantly value your claim for a head injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a neck injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a shoulder injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a elbow injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for an arm injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a hand injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a torso injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a mid-section injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a back injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a leg injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for a knee injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Instantly value your claim for an ankle/foot injury!


Minor Moderate Severe

Find out how much your injury claim is worth!

Click on the injured body part to get your INSTANT FREE personal injury compensation valuation sent to you within seconds...

Yes No

Yes No

Yes No

As Seen on TV
Latest Blog Posts

Breach of duty causing severe leg and foot injuries - Employee suffers a fractured leg and ankle after Galvanising firm fails to instruct him of the safety procedures

"Breach of duty causing severe leg and foot injuries" - Employee suffers a fractured leg and ankle after Galvanising firm fails to instruct him of the safety procedures

If this is not a lesson learnt, then I do not know what is... T & D Galvanising Ltd were found to have breached the duty of care owed to their employee, Mr Ali Zada, who sadly suffered severe i...

Published on the 06/12/2016


Double Amputation as a Result of Employer's Breach of Duty of Care - Cornish Construction Company fined £200,000 after their employee lose both legs

"Double Amputation as a Result of Employer's Breach of Duty of Care" - Cornish Construction Company fined £200,000 after their employee lose both legs

Health and safety in the workplace is so, so important. Getting it right and wrong can literally be the difference between life and death... In this employer's negligence case, an employee of Corni...

Published on the 28/11/2016


Gresley House Residential care home investigation

Gresley House Residential care home investigation

The Care Quality Commission published a report this year on a care home in Derbyshire where it was found that the care home residents had suffered neglect in the form of not being fed properly; being ...

Published on the 21/11/2016


Duty of Care of an Employer - Roofing Company breached a duty of care owed to their employee, after he fell five metres from a roof

"Duty of Care of an Employer" - Roofing Company breached a duty of care owed to their employee, after he fell five metres from a roof

A 32-year-old man sustained severe injuries after falling five metres through a roof he was working on. His employers, the Richardson Roofing Company Limited (RRCL), were found to be liable for his...

Published on the 16/11/2016


Claims for falls in Hospital

Claims for falls in Hospital

Depending on a patient's age, or any medical condition they may have, hospitals have a duty to ensure that risk assessments are carried out to properly care for the vulnerable, and those who are at ri...

Published on the 07/11/2016


How do we calculate what a broken arm injury claim is worth?

How do we calculate what a broken arm injury claim is worth?

Personal injury compensation is awarded to someone who has been involved in an accident that was not their fault. Those that have been injured due to someone else's negligence can generally recover tw...

Published on the 14/10/2016


Worker Suffers nasty injuries after being trapped by three tonne road roller

Worker Suffers nasty injuries after being trapped by three tonne road roller

In November 2015, at Quantum Exhibitions and Displays Ltd in Hipperholme, a 26 year old worker broke his right leg tibia and fibula bones, suffered burns on his right hand, and sustained an open fract...

Published on the 03/10/2016


National Steel firm fined £1.98million for safety failings

National Steel firm fined £1.98million for safety failings

Tata Steel has been fined as two workers suffered hand injuries on two separate incidents involving machinery. A 52-year-old employee lost part of his little finger when his left hand was caught in...

Published on the 23/08/2016


Star Wars Producers plead guilty to failing to protect actors and workers

Star Wars Producers plead guilty to failing to protect actors and workers

Foodles Production (UK) Ltd have pleaded guilty to failing to protect actors and workers on set following an incident where Hollywood actor Harrison Ford suffered a broken leg and other injuries. Harr...

Published on the 16/08/2016


Orthopaedic medical negligence compensation claims

Orthopaedic medical negligence compensation claims

Orthopaedics is commonly the treatment of bones, joints, tendons, muscles, ligaments, and cartilage. These are all elements that make up the musculoskeletal system. Musculoskeletal injuries can aff...

Published on the 10/08/2016


Categories
Archives